Double Play Records by Catchers

Baseball Almanac invites you to examine double play records for catchers. Research is complete through completion of the previous season and includes all of the possible double play record variations.

"Why has our pitching been so great? Our catcher (Yogi Berra) that's why. He looks cumbersome but he's quick as a cat." - Casey Stengel
Double Play Records

Catchers

Record Lg Name Team Data

Fewest
In A Season
By The League Leader

AL

Mike DiFelice

Tampa Bay

8 1998

A.J. Hinch

Oakland

NL

Phil Masi

Boston (1)

8 1949

Pittsburgh (7)

Clyde McCullough

Pittsburgh

Most
In A Career

AL

Ray Schalk

Chicago

217
NL

Gabby Hartnett

Chicago

163

Most
In A Game

AL

Earl Battey

Minnesota

3 08-11-1966

Charlie Berry

Chicago

05-17-1932

Rick Dempsey

Baltimore

06-01-1977

Ed Herrmann

Chicago

07-04-1972

J.C. Martin

Chicago

06-23-1963

Bengie Molina

Anaheim

07-29-2003
NL

Shanty Hogan

New York

3 08-19-1931

Damian Miller

Arizona

05-25-1999

Jack O'Neill

Chicago

04-26-1905

Ebba St. Claire

Boston

08-09-1951

Most
In A Game
Extra Innings

AL

Billy Sullivan

Chicago

3 07-25-1912
10 Innings
NL

Ron Hodges

New York

3 04-23-1978
11 Innings

Bob O'Farrell

Chicago

07-09-1919
10 Innings

Most
In A Season

AL

Steve O'Neill

Cleveland

36 1916
NL

Tom Haller

Los Angeles

23 1968

Most Seasons
Leading The League

AL

Yogi Berra

New York

6 1949

New York

1950

New York

1951

New York

1952

New York

1954

New York

1956
NL

Gabby Hartnett

Chicago

6 1925

Chicago

1927

Chicago

1930

Chicago

1931

Chicago

1934

Chicago

1935
Record Lg Name Team Data

Double Play Records by Catchers



Frank Crossin (St. Louis in 1914) and Jorge Posada (New York in 2000) are the only two catchers in major league history to turn two (2) unassisted double plays during the same season.

On August 19, 1931, Shanty Hogan of the New York Giants became the first catcher to ever start three double plays during a single game. Sixty-eight (68) years later Damian Miller of the Arizona Diamondbacks tied that same record.

On July 29, 2003, Bengie Molina tied the record set by Hogan & Miller (see fact above), but is the first and only player from the American League with the record.