Error Records by First Basemen

Baseball Almanac is pleased to present a record book of baseball milestones for errors by first basemen — including career marks, single season plateaus, and game related records.

"He (George Sisler - tied for American League record in errors scored by a first baseman during a 9-inning game) is the nearest thing to a perfect ballplayer." - Hall of Famer Ty Cobb
Error Records by First Basemen

Career Records

Record Lg Name(s) Team(s) Data

Most
In A Career

AL

Hal Chase

New York

245

285

Chicago

40

NL

Cap Anson

Chicago

568

Error Records by First Basemen

Single Season Records

Record Lg Name(s) Team(s) Data

Fewest
In A Season
150+ Games

AL

Stuffy McInnis

Boston

1

1921

NL

Steve Garvey

San Diego

0

1984

Fewest
In A Season
By The League Leader

AL

Vic Power

Kansas City

10

1955

Gus Triandos

Baltimore

1955

NL

Fred McGriff

San Diego

12

1992

Eddie Murray

New York

1992

Most
In A Season

AL

Jerry Freeman

Washington

41

1908

NL

Cap Anson

Chicago

58

1884

Most Seasons
Leading The League

AL

Mo Vaughn

Boston

6

1992

Boston

1993

Boston

1994

Boston

1996

Boston

1997

Anaheim

2000

NL

Cap Anson

Chicago

5

1882

Chicago

1884

Chicago

1885

Chicago

1886

Chicago

1892

Willie McCovey

San Francisco

1967

San Francisco

1968

San Francisco

1970

San Francisco

1971

San Francisco

1977

Dick Stuart

Pittsburgh

1958

Pittsburgh

1959

Pittsburgh

1960

Pittsburgh

1961

Pittsburgh

1962

Error Records by First Basemen

Game Records

Record Lg Name(s) Team(s) Data

Most
In A Game
9 Innings

AL

Hal Chase

Chicago

4

07-23-1913

Glenn Davis

Baltimore

04-18-1991

George Sisler

St. Louis

04-14-1925

Jimmy Wasdell

Washington

05-03-1939

NL

John Carbine

Louisville

5

04-29-1876

Roger Connor

Troy

05-27-1882

Dude Esterbrook

Buffalo

07-27-1880

Everett Mills

Hartford

10-07-1876

George Zettlein

Philadelphia

06-22-1876

Most
In Any Inning

AL

Catfish Metkovich

Boston

3

04-17-1945

7th Inning

Tommy McCraw

Chicago

05-03-1968

3rd Inning

Willie Upshaw

Toronto

07-01-1986

5th Inning

NL

Dolph Camilli

Philadelphia

3

08-02-1935

7th Inning

Jack Clark

St. Louis

05-25-1987

2nd Inning

Al Oliver

Pittsburgh

05-23-1969

4th Inning

Most Consecutive
Errorless Games
(In A Career)

AL

Kevin Youkilis *

Boston

190

07-05-2006

Boston

Active

* Total current through end of 2007 regular season.

NL

Steve Garvey

San Diego

193

06-26-1983

San Diego

04-14-1985

Most Consecutive
Errorless Games
(In A Season)

AL

Kevin Youkilis

Boston

130

07-05-2006

Boston

09-30-2007

NL

Steve Garvey

San Diego

159

04-03-1984

San Diego

09-29-1984

Record Lg Name(s) Team(s) Data

Error Records by First Basemen



Did you know that since 1900, not one major league ballplayer has ever had more than four errors in a nine-inning game while playing first base?

In the Union Association Joe Quinn of St. Louis played in one-hundred games in 1884 and set the all-time Major League record for errors in a season by a first baseman with sixty-two.

On May 1, 1920, Walter Holke of Boston and Ed Konetchy of Brooklyn played in a twenty-six inning game and set the major league record for longest single game ever played without a single error at first base by either first baseman.