1887 American Association Debuts

Willie Mays played his first Major League game on May 25, 1951, and went 0-for-5 at the plate. He started his career 1-for-25 and told his manager, "I can't do it, Mr. Leo. You better bench me."

Casey Stengel played his first Major League game on July 27, 1912, and went 4-for-4 at the plate. He commented later in his life, "I broke in with four hits and the writers promptly decided they had seen the new Ty Cobb. It took me only a few days to correct that impression."

Both Mays and Stengel would continue their Major League careers down separate paths of greatness, but each still had to appear in that memorable first Major League game. Baseball Almanac is pleased to present what Cubs broadcaster Steve Stone once described as, "His first Major League debut."

"There is a certain amount of fascination to the big league debut of any athlete. Sometimes they are incredible successes. Sometimes they are frenetic failures." - Sportswriter Arthur Daley
American Association Debuts

1887

n/a Law Daniels 1887 Baltimore Orioles 04-25-1887 24
n/a Bill Gardner 1887 Baltimore Orioles 08-09-1887 20
n/a Mike Griffin 1887 Baltimore Orioles 04-16-1887 22
n/a Bob Keating 1887 Baltimore Orioles 08-27-1887 24
n/a Lev Shreve 1887 Baltimore Orioles 05-02-1887 18
n/a Tommy Tucker 1887 Baltimore Orioles 04-16-1887 23
n/a Bert Cunningham 1887 Brooklyn Trolley Dodgers 09-15-1887 21
n/a Billy Otterson 1887 Brooklyn Trolley Dodgers 09-04-1887 25
n/a Heinie Kappel 1887 Cincinnati Red Stockings 05-22-1887 0
n/a Jack O'Connor 1887 Cincinnati Red Stockings 04-20-1887 17
n/a Mike Shea 1887 Cincinnati Red Stockings 04-20-1887 20
n/a George Tebeau 1887 Cincinnati Red Stockings 04-16-1887 25
n/a Mother Watson 1887 Cincinnati Red Stockings 05-19-1887 22
n/a Wild Bill Widner 1887 Cincinnati Red Stockings 06-08-1887 20
n/a Billy Crowell 1887 Cleveland Blues 04-20-1887 21
n/a Ed Flynn 1887 Cleveland Blues 05-05-1887 23
n/a Bob Gilks 1887 Cleveland Blues 08-25-1887 23
n/a Joe Herr 1887 Cleveland Blues 04-16-1887 22
n/a Ed McKean 1887 Cleveland Blues 04-16-1887 22
n/a Mike Morrison 1887 Cleveland Blues 04-19-1887 20
n/a John Munyan 1887 Cleveland Blues 07-12-1887 26
n/a Frank Scheibeck 1887 Cleveland Blues 05-09-1887 21
n/a Hank Simon 1887 Cleveland Blues 10-07-1887 25
n/a Jim Toy 1887 Cleveland Blues 04-20-1887 29
n/a Lave Cross 1887 Louisville Colonels 04-23-1887 20
n/a Ducky Hemp 1887 Louisville Colonels 10-06-1887 24
n/a Bill Collins 1887 New York Metropolitans 10-05-1887 24
n/a Bill Fagan 1887 New York Metropolitans 09-15-1887 18
n/a Charlie Hall 1887 New York Metropolitans 05-03-1887 23
n/a George McMullen 1887 New York Metropolitans 07-02-1887 0
n/a Darby O'Brien 1887 New York Metropolitans 04-16-1887 23
n/a Fred O'Neill 1887 New York Metropolitans 05-03-1887 22
n/a Cyclone Ryan 1887 New York Metropolitans 08-08-1887 0
n/a Pete Sommers 1887 New York Metropolitans 04-27-1887 20
n/a Tommy Casey 1887 Philadelphia Athletics 08-17-1887 0
n/a Fred Chapman 1887 Philadelphia Athletics 07-22-1887 14
n/a Ed Flanagan 1887 Philadelphia Athletics 04-16-1887 25
n/a George Townsend 1887 Philadelphia Athletics 06-25-1887 20
n/a Gus Weyhing 1887 Philadelphia Athletics 05-02-1887 20
n/a Mike Goodfellow 1887 St. Louis Browns 06-13-1887 20
1887 American Association Debuts


 

Find out which players bid farewell to their field's of dreams in the American Association during the 1887 season as this group of players made their Major League debut!

On April 13, 1954, Hank Aaron made his Major League debut and went 0-for-5. However, in his own autobiography Aaron wrote that he went 0-for-4.

Five-for-five debuts? Believe it or not it has happened twice: On June 30, 1894 Fred Clarke of the Louisville Colonels and on May 16, 1933, Cecil Travis of the Washington Senators made their Major League debuts and both went five-for-five at the plate.